To test the my passport formatted for mac, we used the blackmagic disk speed test on a current generation macbook pro. Format the my book drive, open up the encloser and intstal that drive in to my new toy the my cloud. Plus, wd has introduced a series of easytouse apps to increase the my book s. Im no hd expert, so i was hoping to get some opinions about these two drives. While my book comes with backup software, hardware encryption feature and password protection tool. My book vs elements desktop external drives for pc wd. With either drive, you need to keep it very close to the device you are. Which is rarely useful unless you backing up and mirroring your data.
Oct, 2016 to test the my passport formatted for mac, we used the blackmagic disk speed test on a current generation macbook pro. Western digital my book shucking guide get cheaper hard drives. After testing seven hard drives, we found that western digitals 4 tb. Plus, wd has introduced a series of easytouse apps to increase the my book. The basic differences compared to elements are as follows. In hd tune testing, the 4 tb wd my book had a read speed of 143.
To further test the performance of the new wd my passport, we tested with pcmark on the z640 workstation. Western digital has been selling these external storage devices with the highest storage capacity drives in their class for some time now the 3. Wd my passport ultra all versions wd my book for mac. Apr 21, 2020 the readwrite speed of western digital hdds is a little slower compared with seagate, but it is more suitable for storage due to its good stability and durability. Idea listsexplore showroomdiscovertake the home style quiz. Based on 8,730 user benchmarks for the wd elements and the my passport, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 usbs. Besides the shell, wd my book comes with some software tools for backup and drive checking, while wd elements doesnt come preloaded with anything. Hey guys, i lucked out recently and bought cheaply a western digital my book 3tb external hard drive.
I have in my possession both the elements and my passport, let me start off by saying that both are extremely exquisite hard drives. Improve pc performance when your internal hard drive is almost full your pc slows down. The first interesting comparison in the table below is between the my book with the 5400 rpm helioseal drive and the gtechnology gdrive with thunderbolt over usb 3. Western digital elements vs my passport, which one is better. Oct 15, 2015 wd currently has two external desktop drive models, the my book and the elements desktop. Western digitals my book range are powerful external hds that take up more space. The first segment gives the write speed, while the second one gives the read speed for the. Both the western digital elements and the western digital my passport drive use the 3. Designed to meet wds demanding requirements for durability, shock tolerance, and longterm reliability, we back up pun intended. Its likely the actual actual drives on these two are the sameif the passport x has the same drive as the passport ultra, the ultra has the same as the elements.
Dec 06, 2019 both the western digital elements and the western digital my passport drive use the 3. Wd elements is a top selling option in the middle of the external hard drives price range. Western digitals my book thunderbolt duo is about as big as wd. Western digital elements is a great option if you want lots of storage on the cheap, and can live with some pretty mediocre speeds. This isnt a great result which indicates that there are much faster alternatives on. Wd 6tb my book is a popular and one of the more expensive options. Designed to meet wd s demanding requirements for durability, shock tolerance, and longterm reliability, we back up pun intended. With either drive, you need to keep it very close to the device you are working with due to the short length of the cable.
But for the 3tb versions, are the physical drives inside the same. An ample 10tb of storage holds a huge quantity of documents, photos, videos and other data, and 256bit hardware encryption ensures security and privacy. Based on 7,843 user benchmarks for the wd elements and the my book 1140, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 usbs. The good the wd my book duo has plenty of storage space, fast performance, hardware raid, and a builtin twoport usb 3. Compare your components to the current market leaders. What is the difference between wd elements and wd passport. Jan 19, 2017 western digital 8tb unboxing plus speed test 2017 wdbbgb0080hbk desktop drive tim. Sold by baoweikai ltd and ships from amazon fulfillment. The hdd of western digital is relatively stable with low hard drive. In the aja system test, the drive clocked a write speed of 235.
Difference is that wd element is a basic plug n play external drive without any hardware encryption and software or tool. I checked the official website i read the product overview and user. In my recent experience they contain exactly the same models of drives. The 8 tb version of the western digital my book offers reliability, fast transfer speeds. Wd my book hw recognized by cpu, could manually copy files, but unable to do full backup. And the best way to access data in a wd external hard drive which can hardly open is to let easeus data recovery wizard help. While the 1 mb sequential access traces show the 7200 rpm drive in better light.
The third leg the my passport ultra stands on is the. You get a wd smart ware pro which is a nice utility for syncing you data. Wd have since updated and changed their flagship model, though specification and working still remains the same. Heres a list of the drives that do not have hardware encryption on them. Wd backup sw could not find device repeatedly, even w tech support. The compact design offers up to 14tb capacity, making wd elements desktop storage the ideal solution for easy, addon storage of all your important photos, music, videos and files. The small, lightweight drive features up to 5tb of storage with wd quality and reliability. I understand the my book has included software and supports encryption. Dec 18, 2017 western digital managed to pack the same capacity into the my passport ultra using a single drive that requires less logic in the data path. Check out this post for further reference which includes a performance speed test between the two and also unboxing of each. Elements has a sleek and compact design and is a wonderful hard drive if you are looking for something to just dump your data, but if youre looking for something more fancy in terms of design plus a couple of data protection softwares then my passport would.
Amazon have failed to deliver and then cancelled my elements order and they are no longer on offer. This would be good for users without much computer experience. Looking at western digitals warranty information page i see this. Both the wd my passport and wd easystore can be connected via usb 2. I also see people on ebay selling already shucked drives for about same prices but assuming that is a lot riskier since who knows if legitgood drives, etc. The 8tb version of the western digital my book is a deep well of. The new wd my book is both smaller and uses very different design. In conclusion, seagate hard disk drives are generally fast, fluent in reading and writing, and generally light. Western digital elements vs my passport, which one is. I bought a my book 8tb several years ago, and i bought the elements 8tb about a week ago. Oct 11, 2016 here, the new wd my book recorded a pcmark score of 2552 with a bandwidth of 10. Wd external hard drive slow transfer rate and unresponsive.
Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external hdds. Wd element desktop and my book, both are desktop hard drives and have higher data transfer speed with usb 3. Wd currently has two external desktop drive models, the my book and the elements desktop. Testing the readwrite speed of these 2 hard drives 2017 edition usb 3. Its the most proficient hard drive recovery software that takes three steps to help wd users find all data they want. However they have transformed style from a classic stripes design to a futuristic eye candy touch and feel, the white color passport is an eye candy and i personally own one of these and im in love with it, the only drawback is the price for the my passport white version is the. Performance benchmarks western digital my book 8tb and. My passport vs elements unidades externas wd community. Using win 10 on new ssd, wd my book backup sw does not work. I didnt know if both product lines use the same exact drive or is the. The new wd my book is both smaller and uses very different design than the older model, as it now sports angled corners compared to the rounded front panel used before. Based on 2,448 user benchmarks for the wd my book and the my passport, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 usbs. Wd elements price is roughly the same as the price of an average external hard drive. Other than the new design, the drive doesnt have much to elevate it above others.
Hey youtubers, here is the elements desktop 5tb external usb 3. Conclusion overall, wds new my book is a solid choice for the general consumer looking for a solution to back up a large amount of data, such images of their entire computer and large media files, leveraging a relatively large. Explore your best upgrade options with a virtual pc build. Millions of people around the world trust their data to my book desktop storage.
My book uses wd backup software to automatically backup selected file types when added or changed. The external storage device is also affordable, and allows you to. My question is in regards to quality and realiabilty. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my book or wd my passport wireless pro. It has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my book or wd my passport wireless pro. This isnt a great result which indicates that there. Western digital 8tb unboxing plus speed test 2017 wdbbgb0080hbk desktop drive tim. Blackmagic speed test for wd elements 1tb left and wd my passport ultra 4tb right finally, as a simple realworld test i copied a large folder measuring 2. Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on storage. Like its predecessors, the wd black 6tb is designed to give an overall boost for heavier computing tasks, while offering a good cost per tb. Quick little speed test on my new wd my book usb 3. Western digital my book 3tb what are the rps speeds.
This wd my book hard drive is both windows and mac compatible for maximum backup versatility. And it had the fastest time machine backup score of all the 4 tb drives we tested. Wd easystore is similar to wd elements, but is best buy exclusive, and occasionally incredibly cheap per tb cheaper then. If your product is not listed above, please visit the product page. May 08, 2014 testing the readwrite speed of these 2 wd usb 3. Western digitals my book range are powerful external hds that take up more space than its competitors, but offer a lot more storage for a decent price. List of all wd firmware and software available for download. Oct 11, 2016 wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book.
Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has many popular alternatives in the same price range, such as lacie rugged thunderbolt usb or wd my book. For the buffalo drivestation velocity hdlxu3 the figures used are without using the included turbocopy software which averaged slightly slower. I would like to be sure i dont lose data and after reading my book drives. There is a password feature which provides some security. We like that it comes plugandplay ready for windows pcs, so all thats needed to get started is to connect the usb cord from the drive to your pc. Engadget summary no stranger to the portable hard drive space, western digital continues to impress with their my passport ultra, offering usb 3. That said, the lacie porsche design mobile drive performs better overall for this set of artificial benchmark traces. Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options.
1302 739 638 981 149 1499 29 1400 1489 1648 1171 1007 1109 115 132 575 1161 305 18 1246 1222 526 1158 1291 933 327 484 1079 1185 1242 1488 424